Foot Faults · 1930–2004

Foot Faults

Ringers on the interclub team, illegal wine at the first party, a rifled coat, a vanished caretaker, chairs in the pool, a creek buried under the parking lot and thirty years of rows over the town's public courts, told as the papers of the day reported them and no further. Tap a headline to read the story.

Ringers and loose rules

1930The “athletic members”

When the new club entered the Northern California interclub competition in the spring of 1930, it had only two capable players of its own, Dr. Samuel Weiss and Gail Warwick. The club's own history, written by a member in 1946, admits that the rules were then somewhat lax, so the club organized a team of so-called athletic members, picked by Weiss and the professional Kurt Berndt.1 They beat all comers, the history says, including the Berkeley Tennis Club, and the California Tennis Club in the final.1,2

The club's 2024 tournament brochure, retelling the story, calls them by their proper name: a few local “ringers”, recruited to supplement the members on the roster.3

1930Spaghetti, bread and illegal wine

On the last night of the first Marin County championships the players wanted a party. The club rented the Outdoor Art Club, and on a few hours' notice members scoured the county for spaghetti, French bread and, in the words of the 1946 history, illegal wine.1 Prohibition was in force; the brochure of 2024 notes the fact with evident pleasure.3 The Independent Journal in 2026 summed it up: wine was served despite Prohibition.4 The party became the annual Spaghetti Festival.

1949No licence

In April 1949 Mill Valley's assemblyman, Richard McCollister, introduced a bill in Sacramento to allow the Mill Valley Tennis Club a liquor licence, on condition that a club own its premises, have at least a hundred members and have existed for ten years.5 The assembly defeated it within two weeks.6 An Independent Journal history of 2011 nonetheless calls the club the first private club in the state to receive a liquor licence; when that happened, if it did, the papers read for this history do not say.7

Thieves, vandals and a missing caretaker

1933A guest's coat rifled

In September 1933 the police chief took two boys from the Homestead district, aged between ten and twelve, before the county probation officer. They had gone through the pockets of a coat belonging to a guest at the tennis club the day before and taken a wristwatch and some money; the younger boy, the Record said, did the stealing at the older one's bidding.8 The boys were not named, and they got strong advice on straight living.

1948The caretaker and the case of beer

In December 1948 the police swore out a petty-theft warrant for the club's caretaker, who had been missing from his duties for more than a week. Also missing were a case of beer, a case of Coca-Cola, blankets, pillowcases and other things worth about sixty dollars.9 The outcome is not in the papers read.

1963Chairs in the pool

Vandals got into the club over a weekend in August 1963. They slashed a net and cut up a number of chairs, and threw chairs, and a large electric clock, into the swimming pool.10

Rain, schedules and defaults

1931The Mountain Play or Mrs. Moody?

In May 1931 the club's exhibition by Helen Wills Moody and the Mountain Play were set for the same Sunday, at the same hour. The Record reported a caller in despair who had invited guests from Pacific Grove, Stockton and Sacramento for the play but was also a thoroughly addicted tennis fan.11 It rained. Mrs. Moody played a week later, the Mountain Play was put off two weeks, and the tournament's matches were moved to courts in San Francisco to keep the schedule.11,12

1936A wrist sprained at football

Perry Swartz had won the 1936 county singles and doubles at the club and was due to play the mixed doubles final with Helen Bostwick. He defaulted: he had sprained his wrist at football practice at Berkeley, where he was a leading candidate for end on the university varsity.13

1938A split lip and a flying racket

The revived Marin Open of 1938 had its comic moments. Frank Kovacs, on his way to the doubles title, split his lip when he crashed into his partner, Norman Brooks, and several spectators were nearly hit when a racket flew out of Bob Pommer's hand and sailed over their heads.14

Neighbours, fees and the public courts

1939Children off the court

Within a year of the city's courts opening, the rules for them were in dispute. In December 1939 the Mill Valley PTA protested that the rules were too hard on children, and the parks commission recommended striking the age restrictions and reserving only court number one for adults when they were waiting.15 The new rules kept other requirements: tennis shoes without heels, shirts for men and boys, and no smoking while playing.16

1951“Socialistic-communistic grabs”

In May 1951 a proposal to convert all of Boyle Park, the ball field and the tennis courts included, into a public school site was set for a hearing.17 A Citizens Committee for the Preservation of Boyle Park Public Playground started collecting a war chest against what its leader called “socialistic-communistic grabs” of public property. The school board then refused to consider taking the park, which blunted the campaign.18

1964Residents first

The town's public courts were too few for the town's players, and the city tried rule after rule. In 1964 residents were allowed to ask non-residents to leave whenever they wanted to play.19 From 1972 weekend play was for residents with cards, at a dollar a court.20 In 1974 the parks commission voted, after a petition of 119 names, to bar non-residents from the city's tennis lessons; the council undid what one member called a “1 a.m. vote” three weeks later, and another blamed a handful of very effective lobbyists.21,22

1973“Illegal”

In 1973 the city's own recreation supervisor, John Garber, under the name of Garabedian Productions, offered to borrow $30,000 to build two courts and a pro shop at Boyle Park, if the city would make his firm its tennis professional and pay off the loan over ten years.23 The city attorney told the council the plan as written was illegal, the city manager said the town would be paying several times over, and the matter was continued indefinitely.24

1974A road through the parking lot

When residents of Carmelita Avenue complained of cars racing down from the hills in 1974, the council discussed extending Elm Street to Buena Vista as another way down. Such an extension, it was agreed, would cut a swath through the tennis club's parking lot, a possibility bound to generate debate.25 It was sent to the planning commission.

1976Twelve courts, flatly refused

A Tiburon developer offered in 1976 to build a private twelve-court tennis club on four acres of city land, the club to revert to the city after fifteen years. The parks commission rejected it unanimously as a bad deal for the city; the developer said he was flabbergasted.26

1977The locked squeegees

A letter to the Record in November 1977 complained that after a Friday or Saturday night rain three of the Boyle Park courts were unusable for puddles, which squeegees could clear in an hour, but the squeegees were locked up and nobody could be found at the weekend to unlock them.27

1978The pass nobody bought

Told to make the five Boyle Park courts pay for themselves, the city set a $50 yearly pass in 1978.28 By October only 81 seasonal passes had been sold; players without passes simply left the courts when they saw a parks official coming, and the director estimated illegal use as high as 40 percent, and one commissioner admitted that the commission had blown it.29,30 In January 1979 tennis was made free again until July.31

Odd incidents

1973James the crow

In January 1973 the Record's notes column proposed a profile of James the Crow, a large eccentric crow whose beat was Boyle Park, the Mill Valley Tennis Club and the Middle School, and asked readers for tips on how to reach him.32

2004The buried creek

A columnist following Warner Creek upstream in 2004 was dismayed to find it passing under the tennis club's parking lot and grounds in a big culvert. To the builders of the club, he wrote, the creek had been an inconvenience, and they had buried it.33 The founders had indeed planned in 1929 to culvert or fill it.34

That is the list so far. The club was a quiet place by the standards of its neighbours, and the papers of the 1980s to 2000s are only partly read. Living people are named only as the papers named them, and only for what happened on or about the courts.

Sources (34)
  1. Mill Valley Record, Aug. 1, 1946. view source ↗
  2. Mill Valley Record, May 23, 1930. view source ↗
  3. Mill Valley Tennis Club, 2024 Marin Championships tournament brochure, with Jim Tighe's “History of the Marin Championships” (May 2024; mvtc.org PDF; text copy research/pdf/marin_champs_2024.txt). view source ↗
  4. “Tennis: Clubs gearing up for 50th edition of Marin Championships,” Marin Independent Journal, April 25, 2026 (saved copy research/web/005.html; link is a search for the page). view source ↗
  5. Mill Valley Record, April 12, 1949. view source ↗
  6. Mill Valley Record, April 26, 1949. view source ↗
  7. Holly Woolard (column), “Tennis in Marin: County brimming with tennis history,” Marin Independent Journal, March 21, 2011 (saved copy research/web/000.html; link is a search for the page). view source ↗
  8. Mill Valley Record, Sept. 8, 1933. view source ↗
  9. Mill Valley Record, Dec. 10, 1948. view source ↗
  10. Mill Valley Record, Aug. 14, 1963. view source ↗
  11. Mill Valley Record, June 5, 1931. view source ↗
  12. Mill Valley Record, June 5, 1931. view source ↗
  13. Mill Valley Record, Sept. 25, 1936. view source ↗
  14. Mill Valley Record, May 27, 1938. view source ↗
  15. Mill Valley Record, Dec. 1, 1939. view source ↗
  16. Mill Valley Record, Dec. 5, 1939. view source ↗
  17. Mill Valley Record, May 24, 1951 (known from the CDNC search snippet only). view source ↗
  18. Mill Valley Record, June 7, 1951. view source ↗
  19. Mill Valley Record, June 24, 1964. view source ↗
  20. Mill Valley Record, March 15, 1972. view source ↗
  21. Mill Valley Record, June 19, 1974. view source ↗
  22. Mill Valley Record, Aug. 7, 1974. view source ↗
  23. Mill Valley Record, June 27, 1973. view source ↗
  24. Mill Valley Record, Aug. 22, 1973. view source ↗
  25. Mill Valley Record, June 5, 1974. view source ↗
  26. Mill Valley Record, Oct. 20, 1976. view source ↗
  27. Mill Valley Record, Nov. 30, 1977. view source ↗
  28. Mill Valley Record, Aug. 9, 1978. view source ↗
  29. Mill Valley Record, Oct. 4, 1978. view source ↗
  30. Mill Valley Record, Oct. 11, 1978. view source ↗
  31. Mill Valley Record, Jan. 31, 1979. view source ↗
  32. Mill Valley Record, Jan. 10, 1973. view source ↗
  33. Mill Valley Herald, May 4, 2004. view source ↗
  34. Mill Valley Record, Nov. 15, 1929. view source ↗

← Back to the honor roll